Protein Bagel Recipe

So picture this: it’s a chilly Saturday morning in South Philly, fog hangin’ low over the rowhomes, and I’m standin’ in my kitchen with a hot cup of coffee in one hand and flour on the other. That’s when it hit me — I was craving a bagel. Not just any bagel though. I wanted one that didn’t knock me out with carbs before noon but still gave me that chewy, toasty, hearty bite I grew up on. That’s how this protein bagel recipe was born.

If you're into easy breakfast ideas like this, you might also like my Cinnamon Roll Honeybun Cheesecake, the classic twist on quick treats like the Diet Coke and Cake Mix Recipe, or my other favorite bagel spin — the Cottage Cheese Bagel Recipe.

Now, let me tell ya, I didn’t always mess around with things like Greek yogurt and baking powder instead of yeast. Back in the day, Nonna would raise an eyebrow if I told her I was skippin’ the yeast. "You makin’ a science project or breakfast?" she’d say. But honestly, once I started playin’ with these 3 ingredient protein bagels, I got hooked. It’s just flour, baking powder, and good ol’ full-fat Greek yogurt. Boom — no proofing, no stress.

These bagels check all the boxes: low calorie, high protein bagel recipe, no weird powders, no kitchen gymnastics. Just mix, roll, bake, and boom — breakfast is handled for the week. And if you top 'em with smashed avocado, scallion cream cheese, or some egg whites, you're sittin’ on one heck of a protein-packed start to the day.

These babies come out crisp on the outside, soft and chewy inside — everything you want in a bagel. And guess what? You don’t even need an oven if you’ve got an air fryer handy. Just preheat that sucker, pop these in, and you’ve got golden brown perfection in 20 minutes.

Wanna make it even better? Try the protein bagel recipe with cottage cheese variation — just swap the yogurt with blended cottage cheese. Or go classic with protein bagel recipe Greek yogurt if you're like me and keep tubs of Fage 5% in the fridge at all times.

Now lemme hit you with some of my go-to high protein bagel toppings:
• Scrambled egg whites and scallion cream cheese
• Peanut butter and banana
• Avocado, chili flakes, and a soft-boiled egg
• Smoked salmon, capers, and whipped Greek yogurt with lemon

Best part? These are make-ahead champs. Store ‘em in the fridge, toast when needed, and boom — breakfast or post-workout fuel without any hassle.

Here are some questions folks often ask me…

Are protein bagels healthy?
Yeah, I’d say they’re a pretty solid pick. You’re lookin’ at about 10g of protein per bagel, not too much fat (depends on the yogurt), and a whole lot less mystery than store-bought stuff.

How do they make high-protein bagels?
Simple — they swap out the yeast and long proofing for baking powder and load in the Greek yogurt. No fancy powders, just pantry basics.

What are the two ingredients in protein bagels?
If you're keepin’ it super simple: Greek yogurt and self-rising flour. But the version I use adds salt, baking powder, and egg white for that perfect finish.

What makes bagels so high in protein?
It’s mostly the Greek yogurt, honestly. That stuff is like the secret weapon in the fridge — full of flavor, thick, creamy, and packed with protein.

Protein Bagel Recipe

Print